Second Best

This is a true story.

When I was at university I had a gorgeous girlfriend. One afternoon, I decided to drop by and surprise her (hoping for a quickie). Her front door was unlocked, which was strange, and she didn’t hear my knocking. So I went in.

I called out and went up the stairs, passing the other rooms to her bedroom. I heard the front door open and close and thought it must’ve been her flatmate heading out. I went into her room and found her in bed – naked. She said she’d been having a nap (but she never did that naked). Turned on by the sight of her amazing naked body, I began kissing and sucking her. She moaned and responded.

I took off my clothes and brought my cock to her pussy. It slid in easily, her pussy already hot and wet – and softer than I had ever felt it before. As I felt her soft pussy around my cock, I started to realise the truth. She’d just been fucking someone else. Someone with a very big cock. She’d never cheated on me before. But there was something in her eyes as we fucked. A secret in her eyes. A slight smile in the corner of her mouth. The thought of another man’s cock inside her drove me crazy and I came harder than I ever have in my life.

We never spoke about it and we broke up for other reasons a year or two later, but I always look back on that day with very fond memories of feeling her freshly fucked body, and knowing (by the softness of her pussy) that I was second best that day.